3 Symptoms of a Bad Starter Solenoid (Replacement Cost in 2025)

Few situations are more frustrating for drivers than turning the key and hearing nothing but silence. While starting problems can come from various sources, a faulty starter solenoid is often the root cause that many motorists overlook.

Understanding the warning signs of a bad starter solenoid can help you diagnose the issue quickly and potentially save hundreds in repair costs. Here’s what you need to know about this essential starting system component and how to spot trouble before it leaves you stranded.

Table of Contents

Starter Solenoid vs Starter Relay

There is often some degree of confusion that exists surrounding the differences between a vehicle’s starter solenoid and starter relay. In truth, these components differ from one another in multiple ways.

While the starting solenoid controls the operation of the starter’s Bendix and completes the power distribution circuit to the starter itself, the starter relay, when engaged, amplifies the battery’s current thereby preventing excess strain on a vehicle’s battery during starting.

A vehicle’s starting solenoid is typically mounted externally to the starter itself, as part of a larger starter assembly. On the contrary, a vehicle’s starter relay is usually found within the underhood fuse box, in the engine bay. This relay is much smaller than a vehicle’s starter solenoid and is inserted into specified terminals within the above-mentioned fuse block.

Bad Starter Solenoid Symptoms

In almost every case, the failure or impending failure of a starter solenoid is accompanied by one or more secondary symptoms, most of which will prevent a vehicle’s engine from starting. Recognizing these symptoms is the first step to reaching a timely diagnosis.

#1 – Silent When Starting

One of the most common symptoms of starter solenoid failure is a lack of noticeable starting system response when a vehicle’s start button is pressed or the ignition is keyed to the “run” position.

In most cases, no starter motor actuation will be heard, nor will clicking from the starter solenoid be evident. However, in other cases, only a single click might be heard.

#2 – Intermittent “No-Crank” Events

Another common symptom of impending starter solenoid failure is intermittent “no-crank” events. If your vehicle’s engine occasionally fails to crank, only to start as intended a few moments later, it is very possible that the starter solenoid is to blame.

Unfortunately, such episodes often progress in frequency until complete failure occurs.

#3 – Grinding of Starter When Cranking

It is also not uncommon for a grinding noise to be heard during attempted starting, as a starter solenoid begins to fail. This is due to the fact that the starter solenoid also controls starter-to-ring gear engagement.

Improper alignment between these surfaces can occur if the starter solenoid fails to engage fully.

Beware of False Online Information

One should beware of false information presented on the internet, regarding the diagnosis and repair of automotive issues. This rings especially true when attempting to diagnose starting-related issues.

It’s best to steer clear of any pages that seem to confuse or interchange the terms “starter relay” and “starter solenoid”. These components are not one in the same, and should not be treated as such.

Additionally, avoid taking stock in advice that suggests you should replace a certain component, simply because you hear a certain noise or don’t. There is a diagnostic process associated with troubleshooting starting issues.

Attempting to replace parts in the manner described above, without having a solid diagnosis, is a sure way to waste money on the replacement of components that did not require replacement.

Replacement Cost

Best places to order parts? See: 19 Best Online Auto Parts Stores

The cost associated with starter solenoid replacement often varies from one make and model of vehicle to the next. There is also some variance in cost associated with how, exactly, repair is tackled.

Though it is possible to replace only the starter solenoid, the starter and starter solenoid are typically replaced as a unitized assembly.

Assuming that the entire starter assembly is to be replaced, as is common practice, you can expect to pay somewhere in the range of $400-$750 to fix your vehicle’s starting solenoid issues. However, significant money can be saved by conducting the work yourself, as over half of the price above can be attributed solely to labor.

Furthermore, those handy with a wrench can save even more money by replacing just their starter assembly’s solenoid, though this often proved somewhat more involved.

What Causes a Starter Solenoid to Fail?

A starter solenoid can fail for a number of reasons, the most common of which centers around typical wear and tear. With time, the internal electrical contacts within a starter solenoid can degrade, therefore becoming less conductive.

Additionally, due to the location of the starter/starter solenoid on most vehicles, water contamination and corrosion are also a major concern and potential cause of failure.

It’s also important to note that all electrical leads and wiring to a vehicle’s starter solenoid should be periodically inspected. It is not uncommon for voltage drop caused by poor electrical connections to pose starter solenoid-related issues.

With time, this excess resistance within the starting circuit can take a toll on a vehicle’s starting solenoid, due to the generation of additional heat.

Diagnosing a Bad Starter Solenoid

The following steps can be used to assist in pinpointing and diagnosing starter solenoid-related issues. Before you begin, it’s highly recommended to get a factory-specific service manual for your particular vehicle model.

Step #1 – Check Battery Voltage

Begin by checking your vehicle’s battery voltage with the use of a quality multimeter. This meter should be set to its DC voltage scale, and both leads should be touched to the battery’s corresponding posts, based on polarity.

Ideally, a battery, when measured statically, should show a charge of 12.6V.

Step #2 – Assess Voltage Drop

Next, with your multimeter and leads arranged as described above, have an assistant attempt to crank the vehicle. Carefully watch the voltage reading present on the meter. This reading should not drop below 9.6V. A voltage drop exceeding this value would signify the need for a new battery.

Step #3 – Inspect Starter Solenoid Connections/Leads

Now, carefully inspect all electrical leads at your vehicle’s starter/starter solenoid for loose connections or signs of corrosion. Any underlying conditions of the like should be repaired before proceeding.

Step #4 – Verify Ignition Feed at “S” Terminal

At this point, it will be necessary to verify all inputs at the starter solenoid. This will involve ensuring that a 12V+ battery feed is present at the inlet terminal to the solenoid. Assuming that this feed is present, you will need to ensure that 12V is being distributed to the solenoid’s “S” terminal, while an assistant attempts to crank the vehicle.

If no positive voltage is recorded at this terminal, an ignition switch or wiring issue should be suspected. If this feed is present, yet battery voltage is not present at the outlet side of the assembly, a faulty starter solenoid is likely to blame. This can be confirmed through further continuity testing as described in OE service literature.

Author
Recent Posts

Josh Boyd

Josh has worked as a full-time mechanic for over 12 years, with 6 ASE (Automotive Service Excellence) certifications under his belt. He began his career as an automotive technician at local Toyota dealership and has since transitioned to specializing in diesel trucks and equipment.

3 Symptoms of a Bad Starter Solenoid (and Replacement Cost)