5 Symptoms of a Bad Hydraulic Lifter (and Replacement Cost)

Your vehicle’s hydraulic valve lifters, or hydraulic tappets, are small cylinders right beside each of your engine’s valves that help your engine run smoothly and quietly. Over time, the lifter mechanism will wear out (especially with dirty oil or not enough of it), leading to a lifter ticking or tapping sound.

If you ignore this sound or other signs of a bad lifter, the problem can worsen and possibly cause severe damage to your vehicle. To help avoid the expensive consequences of overlooking a faulty hydraulic lifter, we’ve put together a list of bad lifter symptoms you should never ignore.

bad lifter symptoms

How Do Hydraulic Lifters Work?

A small rod, known as the rocker arm, connects the hydraulic valve to the lifter. Unlike other lifters, a hydraulic lifter contains oil, which drives its plunger and spring.

The plunger and spring work together to create clearance within the valve train and ensure quieter driving. The hydraulic filter also increases the lifespan of your engine by reducing wear and tear.

Low oil pressure within a hydraulic lifter can affect its performance and generate unusual noises. If ignored, the problem can escalate until it damages the valve tip, rocker arm, and push rod, which all amount to expensive fixes.

What Does a Bad Lifter Sound Like?

Knowing what a faulty lifter sounds like can save you hundreds of dollars by helping you catch and fix a lifter problem early. Instead of the occasional knocking, a bad hydraulic lifter will make a continuous tapping sound.

The tapping will occur in rapid succession and will worsen with time. Depending on the exact issue, the sound can occur regardless of whether you have a hot or cold engine. For more severe lifter problems, you may hear a loud knocking or banging noise.

See Also: What Does Rod Knock Sound Like?

Bad Lifter Symptoms

damaged hydraulic lifter
damaged lifter

In addition to noisy valve lifters, other symptoms of a faulty hydraulic lifter include:

#1 – Sticky Lifters

A sticky lifter remains in a collapsed state instead of going up and down. When the lifter doesn’t move, the system becomes unable to maintain oil pressure. It will also lead to the lifter’s internal parts hammering against one other, generating more noise.

#2 – More RPM Causes More Noise

Because of the faulty components, accelerating to a higher RPM will increase the volume and frequency of the lifter noise.

#3 – Misfires

A faulty lifter will disrupt a cylinder’s ability to mix and burn air and fuel. When that happens, cylinder misfiring occurs, and you experience slower acceleration.

#4 – Dead Cylinder

The malfunctioning lifter will cause the pushrod to bend and fall out of space. When that happens, it leads to a dead cylinder that might break valves, rocker arms, or even damage the entire engine.

#5 – Check Engine Light

As the problem intensifies, your check engine light will come on. You can then diagnose the problem by checking the listed error codes.

Engine Lifter Replacement Cost

Best places to order parts?  See: 19 Best Online Auto Parts Stores

engine lifter replacement cost

The cost of replacing an engine lifter isn’t so cut and dry due to so many factors. Sure, if only one lifter is bad and you choose to only replace that one, getting a replacement cost figure is pretty straightforward. But like spark plugs, it’s a good idea to simply replace them all because if one goes bad, others will likely soon follow.

The cost of a lifter itself ranges anywhere from $5 to $30. But if you’re replacing all the lifters in your engine, that can vary greatly depending on the engine.

Generally speaking, there are two lifters per valve. This means that you may need to replace 2 lifters or 32 lifters or somewhere in between. Add to that the cost of gaskets, bolts, and other parts and it can get quite expensive.

An alternative is to purchase a complete lifter replacement kit such as this one for a 2007-2014 GM 5.3L engine. The price of an aftermarket kit is going to be better than purchasing individual OEM parts from a dealership, but you need to consider quality as well.

Labor costs aren’t going to be cheap either. Again, depending on the engine, it can be a 3-hour job, 10-hour job, or somewhere in between. Using an average $100/hr labor rate, you’re looking at somewhere between $300 and $1,000 just for labor.

When talking about the total replacement cost (parts + labor), giving an average cost is hard to give. But as an example, for a common V8 engine that has 16 lifters, expect to pay somewhere between $1,000 to $2,000 depending on the quality of parts and whether going to an independent mechanic or the dealership.

You could save a bit of money by getting refurbished lifters instead of brand new ones but that’s not going to affect your labor cost so it’s generally not recommended.

How to Quiet Noisy Lifters

If you want to prevent noisy valve lifters, use these tips:

Regular Oil Changes

Getting an oil change at the right time will prevent dirty oil or low oil levels from damaging the lifter. Make sure you are using the correct engine oil to avoid lifter noise.

Use an Oil Additive

A good oil additive like Liqui Moly or Marvel Mystery Oil can improve the quality of engine oil and clean the lifters. These additives also clean rocker arms, valves, and other engine parts. This is a best-case scenario since it’s a cheap fix.

Adjust the Lifter Spacing

If the lifter noise persists, even though there’s nothing wrong with it, have a professional mechanic modify the spacing between the lifter and other engine components. Vehicle manuals typically specify the ideal lifter spacing.

What Causes a Bad or Collapsed Lifter?

The lifter malfunction may occur due to:

Mark Stevens


  1. I have a knocking noise on my 2009 GMC SIERRA 1500 5.3 motor .idk if it’s the lifters or my flex plate .how can I tell the difference

    1. It’s going to be hard to tell without someone experienced taking a look at your motor. Even then, it’s a best guess. I’ve had a mechanic misdiagnose a noise in my engine and tell me it was a rod bearing, when the root cause was actually a chewed up keyway on the nose of the crankshaft.

  2. I have noise when driving in a uneven road. Tapping sounds in bonnet left hand side. This noise consider as tapperrt.

    Thank you

    1. Could your struts or top hats be loose? Maybe a bad suspension bushing? You’ll have to have someone take a look at it and replicate the issue at a shop or something.

  3. My 2013 chevy silverado started tapping a few months ago. My dealership informed me that I will be needing a new motor. Fouled plug, oil on threads of plug. Does this mean I will need a new motor or just replace lifter? Any suggestions will be greatly appreciated.

    1. I don’t know. You could try picking up an automotive borescope, doing a compression test, doing a leak down test, or sending some oil into a company like Blackstone for a used oil analysis. Those four things should give you a much better idea about the state of your engine.

    2. Kimberli,

      If your truck starts easily in any weather, whether it is cold or has been driven recently, idles smoothly in gear, accelerates normally, and will cruise comfortably at highway speed, do not worry. Have your oil and filter changed immediately, and from now on, have the oil and filter changed every three thousand miles. Millions of Chevrolet engines make light tapping sounds for years without any damage to the engine or reliability. An actual mechanic in your area will perform a “vacuum test” and ensure that your oil pressure is normal. This mechanic can determine most issues with your car, within ten minutes, to include a short test drive. Now remember if your oil pressure light comes on, pull over and listen to your engine idling, then drive to an actual service station and get them to check and add oil if required.

  4. Very interesting article to be sure. Didn’t see what I was looking into though, I have a 1997 Firebird with a LT1 and I changed roller lifters, pushrods, and rocker arms. Pushrods are Melling, don’t recall lifter brand. The driver’s side front lifter (exhaust?) doesn’t pump oil in pulses but in a continuous stream. The rocker is moving. What could be causing this? Bad new lifter check ball stuck? I’ve never seen anything like this.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *